Garrett ACE 200 vs. Garrett ACE 300: Which Metal Detector is Right for You?

If you’re new to the world of metal detecting or simply looking to upgrade your gear, choosing the right metal detector can be a daunting task. Garrett, a trusted name in the industry, offers two excellent entry-level options: the Garrett ACE 200 and the Garrett ACE 300. Both models are designed to provide a user-friendly experience for beginners, but each comes with its own set of features that cater to different needs. In this comparison, we’ll break down the key differences between these two detectors, from their design and functionality to their performance in the field, to help you make an informed decision.

1. Garrett ACE 200 Metal Detector

The Garrett ACE 200 Metal Detector is an excellent option for both adults and kids looking to get into treasure hunting without breaking the bank. This detector is lightweight at just 2.75 pounds, making it comfortable for users of all ages to handle for extended periods. Its easy-to-use design and clear LCD display ensure that beginners can quickly start detecting coins, jewelry, and other treasures. The 6.5” x 9” elliptical searchcoil works well in various conditions, and its waterproof feature adds versatility for beach and shallow water searches. Users also appreciate the 3-year warranty, which adds peace of mind for those new to the hobby.

While the ACE 200 delivers solid performance, it does have its limitations. The 7 KHz operating frequency works well for general searches, but it may struggle with deeper or smaller targets. The detector has only three programs, which may not offer the level of customization some experienced users might desire. Additionally, the battery-powered design means you’ll need to keep spare batteries on hand.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

1. Easy to use, perfect for beginners
2. Lightweight and adjustable for comfort
3. Waterproof searchcoil for versatility
4. Clear LCD display for easy target identification
5. 3-year warranty adds value

Cons:

1. Limited to three programs

2. Garrett ACE 300 Metal Detector

The Garrett ACE 300 Metal Detector is a great option for those who want a bit more precision and versatility than entry-level detectors. It offers a digital target ID system with a numeric scale (0-99) to help identify the conductivity of metals, making it easier to distinguish between valuable items and trash. The improved iron resolution feature allows for better discrimination, reducing the frustration of detecting unwanted iron objects. Additionally, the adjustable frequency helps minimize interference from nearby detectors, providing a smoother experience in crowded areas. Users also appreciate the inclusion of free accessories, like the ClearSound headphones and environmental cover-up, adding even more value to this already affordable package.

While the ACE 300 delivers solid performance, it’s not without its limitations. Some users may find the lack of more advanced features limiting, especially if they have specific detecting needs. The battery-powered design, while convenient, could lead to the inconvenience of changing batteries on longer hunts. Moreover, despite the good build quality, the detector can feel a bit bulky after extended use. The detector’s depth capabilities may also not match those of more expensive models.

Pros and Cons

Pros:

1. Digital target ID for precise detection
2. Improved iron resolution for better discrimination
3. Adjustable frequency to reduce interference
4. Easy to use, ideal for beginners
5. Includes useful accessories like headphones and cover-up

Cons:

1. Depth detection may not match more advanced models

Garrett ACE 200 vs. Garrett ACE 300: A Comparison

When it comes to choosing a metal detector for beginners or casual users, the Garrett ACE series offers two solid options: the ACE 200 and ACE 300. Both models are manufactured by Garrett, a well-known brand in the metal detecting world, but they cater to different user needs with some important differences in features, performance, and value.

Design and Build Quality

Both the Garrett ACE 200 and ACE 300 are designed with ease of use in mind, making them ideal for newcomers to metal detecting. Both detectors are lightweight and feature an adjustable shaft, which ensures comfort during long hunting sessions. The ACE 200 weighs just 2.75 pounds, while the ACE 300 is slightly heavier at 2.9 pounds. The build quality of both models is solid, with the ACE 300 offering a more robust design and additional features like a more advanced control panel.

The ACE 300 includes a larger 7″ x 10″ searchcoil compared to the ACE 200’s 6.5″ x 9″ elliptical searchcoil, which gives it a slight edge in terms of coverage area. Both coils are waterproof, allowing users to search in shallow water without worrying about damaging the device. The ACE 300 also has the added advantage of a headphone jack, which comes with ClearSound Easy Stow headphones, improving audio clarity during searches.

Target Detection and Features

One of the key differences between the ACE 200 and ACE 300 lies in their detection capabilities. Both detectors use a digital target ID system, but the ACE 300 offers a more advanced version with a numeric scale (0–99) that provides more detailed information about the target’s conductivity. This feature is particularly useful for users who want more precision in identifying potential treasures.

The ACE 300 also has better discrimination features. The Iron Resolution on the ACE 300 allows for better separation of valuable targets from iron trash, making it more effective at filtering out unwanted signals. The ACE 200, while still having discrimination capabilities, doesn’t offer the same level of accuracy in differentiating metals.

Furthermore, the ACE 300 features an Electronic Pinpointing mode, which is useful for accurately locating detected targets. The ACE 200 does have a basic pin-pointer function, but it is not as advanced as the ACE 300’s pinpointing capabilities. This makes the ACE 300 a better choice for users looking for more precision and ease when pinpointing the exact location of a target.

Feature	Garrett ACE 200	Garrett ACE 300
Searchcoil Size	6.5″ x 9″ Elliptical	7″ x 10″
Digital Target ID	Basic Target ID	Numeric Scale (0-99)
Discrimination	Standard Discrimination	Improved Iron Resolution
Pinpointing	Basic Pinpointing	Electronic Pinpointing
Frequency	7 kHz	Adjustable Frequency

Ease of Use and Setup

Both models are designed with simplicity in mind. The ACE 200 is extremely user-friendly, making it perfect for beginners who are just starting out with metal detecting. It is easy to set up, with minimal controls to manage, and it has an intuitive LCD display that provides the most basic information necessary for treasure hunting.

On the other hand, the ACE 300 has a slightly more complex interface due to its additional features, but it is still quite user-friendly. The larger display offers more detailed information, and the added discrimination options give users more control over the search. It’s an excellent choice for those who want more precision but don’t want to jump into a complex, professional-level detector.

Both models come with adjustable shafts that extend up to 53 inches, making them suitable for users of various heights, from children to adults.

Accessories and Warranty

The ACE 300 comes with a set of useful accessories, including the ClearSound Easy Stow Headphones, an environmental cover-up, and a searchcoil cover, which enhances the value of the package. These accessories make it easier for users to get started right away and ensure that their detector is well-protected. The ACE 200, on the other hand, does not come with as many extras but still includes a basic set-up that is more than adequate for most users.

Both detectors are backed by a 3-year warranty, which is reassuring for buyers, especially those who are new to metal detecting. This warranty demonstrates Garrett’s confidence in the durability and reliability of their products, giving customers peace of mind.

Performance in the Field

In terms of field performance, both the ACE 200 and ACE 300 perform well for casual metal detecting. The ACE 200 is ideal for simple searches, offering great value for the money for those who are looking for basic functionality and ease of use. However, the ACE 300 offers more versatility and precision, making it a better option for those who want to progress in the hobby or encounter more challenging detecting environments.

The ACE 300’s ability to adjust the frequency helps minimize interference in areas with multiple detectors, making it more suitable for crowded detecting locations like beaches or parks. It also provides better depth capabilities and more accurate target identification, which can make a big difference in finding valuable items like coins and jewelry.

FAQ

What is the main difference between the Garrett ACE 200 and ACE 300?

The main difference between the ACE 200 and ACE 300 is the level of features and functionality. The ACE 300 offers a more advanced digital target ID system with a numeric scale (0-99), allowing for more precise identification of metals. It also features improved iron resolution, which helps distinguish valuable targets from unwanted iron trash. Additionally, the ACE 300 includes an electronic pinpointing mode, which makes it easier to accurately locate targets. In contrast, the ACE 200 has a simpler interface and fewer features, making it ideal for absolute beginners.

Can both detectors be used underwater?

Both the Garrett ACE 200 and ACE 300 come with waterproof search coils, which allow you to use them in shallow water, such as beaches or streams. However, neither detector is fully waterproof, so the control boxes should not be submerged. The search coils can handle wet conditions, but it’s important to keep the control unit dry for safe operation.

Is the Garrett ACE 300 suitable for more experienced users?

While the Garrett ACE 300 is primarily designed for beginners and intermediate users, its additional features like adjustable frequency and better target discrimination make it suitable for users who want to improve their metal detecting skills. However, if you’re an experienced metal detectorist looking for advanced depth capabilities and features, you may want to consider a more high-end model for professional-level performance.

How long do the batteries last in these detectors?

Both the ACE 200 and ACE 300 are battery-powered, and the battery life can vary depending on usage. Generally, you can expect around 20-30 hours of operation from a set of 4 AA batteries, though this can vary depending on factors such as terrain, frequency settings, and the use of headphones. It’s a good idea to carry extra batteries during longer hunts to avoid interruptions. Neither model offers a rechargeable battery option, so users need to have spare batteries on hand.

Are the Garrett ACE 200 and ACE 300 easy to set up?

Yes, both the Garrett ACE 200 and ACE 300 are designed for easy setup and use. The ACE 200 is especially beginner-friendly with its simple controls and quick assembly. The ACE 300, while slightly more advanced, still has an intuitive interface that makes it easy to get started. Both detectors come with clear instructions, and users can begin detecting in just a few minutes after unpacking.

Conclusion

Both the Garrett ACE 200 and ACE 300 are excellent choices for beginners, but the ACE 300 offers more advanced features that cater to those who want to take their metal detecting to the next level. While the ACE 200 is simple, affordable, and easy to use, the ACE 300 provides enhanced target identification, better discrimination, and more precise pinpointing, making it a better choice for those looking for greater accuracy and versatility.

Summary:

• Garrett ACE 200: Best for beginners who want a straightforward and affordable option for metal detecting. Offers basic features and ease of use.
• Garrett ACE 300: Ideal for those who want more precision, better discrimination, and additional features like adjustable frequency and electronic pinpointing. It’s a solid mid-range detector that offers great value for the money.

Enjoyed this guide of Garrett ACE 250 vs 300 vs 400? Then be sure to check out our other metal detector guides.

• Best Metal Detectors for Beach
• Best Metal Detector Pinpointers
• Best Metal Detectors for Beginners
• Best Metal Detectors for Kids
• Best Sand Scoop for Metal Detecting
• Best Metal Detectors for Coin Hunting