Fisher F44 vs. Garrett ACE 400: A Comprehensive Comparison

When it comes to metal detecting, choosing the right tool can make all the difference in your treasure hunting experience. Two popular options among enthusiasts are the Fisher F44 and the Garrett ACE 400. Both detectors offer a solid balance of features, performance, and ease of use, but they each cater to different needs. Whether you’re a beginner looking for a user-friendly device or an experienced detectorist seeking more advanced features, this comparison will help you decide which model best suits your requirements. In this guide, we’ll dive deep into the key differences and similarities between the Fisher F44 and Garrett ACE 400, covering everything from their design and performance to their value for money.

Fisher F44 Metal Detector

The Fisher F44 Metal Detector is an excellent choice for treasure hunters of all experience levels, offering a perfect balance between performance and ease of use. It features a weatherproof design, making it a durable companion for outdoor adventures in all kinds of weather, from sunny days to rainy conditions. The large, easy-to-read LCD display ensures that users can quickly identify their finds, while the advanced sensitivity technology allows for the detection of even the smallest and most deeply buried metals. This makes it perfect for searching parks, beaches, and fields. The detector also boasts adjustable discrimination, target depth indicators, and audio feedback, which help to fine-tune your search and focus on valuable targets while ignoring unwanted metals.

A key advantage of the Fisher F44 is its portability, powered by batteries, which means you can take it anywhere without the need for an outlet or worrying about cords. This feature enhances its convenience for those who prefer long treasure hunting sessions. The Fisher F44 offers an ideal mix of value, ease of use, and reliability, which is why it is highly rated and recognized as Amazon’s Choice.

Key Features, Pros, and Cons

Key Features:

1. Weatherproof design for all-weather outdoor use.
2. Large, easy-to-read LCD display for clear target information.
3. Advanced sensitivity technology for detecting small and deeply buried metals.
4. Adjustable discrimination, target depth indicators, and audio feedback.
5. Battery-powered for portable and flexible use.

Pros:

1. Durable construction that withstands various weather conditions.
2. User-friendly interface suitable for both beginners and experienced users.
3. High sensitivity for detecting even the smallest metals.
4. Lightweight and easy to handle, making it ideal for long hunts.
5. Great value for money with reliable performance.

Cons:

1. Battery-powered, requiring regular battery replacements.
2. Some users may find the LCD display slightly difficult to view in direct sunlight.

Garrett ACE 400 Metal Detector

The Garrett ACE 400 Metal Detector offers a fantastic balance of performance and affordability, making it an ideal option for beginners and intermediate treasure hunters alike. One of its standout features is the Digital Target ID system, which uses a 0-99 numeric scale to help identify the conductivity of various metals, allowing for more precise target identification. This makes the device much easier to use when searching for valuable items, as you can quickly determine the type of metal before digging. Additionally, the Iron Audio feature helps users hear unwanted targets like bottle caps and washers, which is particularly useful when sifting through trashy areas. The electronic pinpointing function further enhances accuracy, helping to locate targets with precision in all-metal mode.

The ACE 400 is also equipped with an adjustable frequency, which helps reduce interference from electrical sources or other detectors, ensuring smooth operation in crowded areas. It comes with several useful accessories, including ClearSound Easy Stow Headphones, an ACE Environmental Cover-Up, and a searchcoil cover, which add great value to the package.

Key Features, Pros, and Cons

Key Features:

1. Digital Target ID with a 0-99 numeric scale for precise target identification.
2. Iron Audio feature to hear unwanted metal targets like bottle caps.
3. Electronic pinpointing mode for accurate target location.
4. Adjustable frequency to minimize interference from other detectors.
5. Comes with useful accessories, including headphones and a searchcoil cover.

Pros:

1. Easy to use, making it ideal for beginners.
2. Provides accurate pinpointing of targets.
3. The Iron Audio feature helps to avoid digging unwanted items.
4. Adjustable frequency minimizes interference in crowded areas.
5. Great value for money with the included accessories.

Cons:

1. Battery-powered, which requires regular replacements.
2. May not be as deep-penetrating as higher-end models.

Fisher F44 vs. Garrett ACE 400: Detailed Comparison

When choosing a metal detector, two popular models that often come up for comparison are the Fisher F44 and the Garrett ACE 400. Both detectors are designed to offer solid performance for a variety of treasure hunting needs, from beginners to more seasoned hunters. However, they come with distinct features that can make one more appealing than the other depending on your specific requirements.

Design and Build Quality

Fisher F44
The Fisher F44 has a durable, weatherproof design that allows it to withstand harsh outdoor conditions, making it an ideal choice for all-weather treasure hunts. Whether it’s raining or sunny, you can take this detector to beaches, parks, or fields without worrying about the elements. It’s built to be sturdy yet lightweight, which makes it easy to carry during extended hunts. The large LCD display is clear and easy to read, adding to its user-friendly design.

Garrett ACE 400
The Garrett ACE 400, on the other hand, has a solid build but lacks the weatherproof features of the F44. It is more lightweight, but it may not perform as well in wet conditions. However, it compensates for this with an adjustable frequency feature that minimizes interference from electrical sources, making it a good option for hunting in crowded areas. The build is also plastic, which may not feel as premium as the metal components of some higher-end detectors. The included accessories, such as headphones and a searchcoil cover, add some value to the package.

Key Features Comparison

Feature	Fisher F44	Garrett ACE 400
Weatherproof Design	Yes	No
LCD Display	Large, easy-to-read	Basic display
Target Identification	Sensitivity and target depth indicators	Digital Target ID (0-99 scale)
Iron Audio Feature	No	Yes (Helps discriminate unwanted targets)
Pinpointing	Standard pinpointing mode	Electronic Pinpointing (accurate location)
Adjustable Frequency	No	Yes (Reduces interference)
Accessories Included	None	Headphones, Environmental Cover-Up, and searchcoil cover

Performance

Fisher F44
The Fisher F44 is equipped with sensitive detection technology, making it capable of locating even the smallest and most deeply buried metals. It has an adjustable discrimination setting, which allows you to ignore unwanted metals and focus on valuable finds. Additionally, it has a great depth range, which allows it to be effective in various environments. The Fisher F44’s weatherproof design makes it a reliable tool for year-round treasure hunting, no matter the weather conditions.

Garrett ACE 400
The Garrett ACE 400 is also a powerful detector, featuring a digital target ID that helps to identify metal types with a 0-99 scale, giving users a good idea of what they are digging up. The iron audio feature is particularly valuable when detecting in areas with a lot of trash, as it helps you avoid unnecessary digging of undesirable metals like bottle caps. The ACE 400 also boasts electronic pinpointing, which aids in accurately locating targets, making recovery much easier. Its adjustable frequency is another great advantage when working in areas with a lot of interference from other detectors or electrical sources.

Usability and Accessories

Fisher F44
The F44’s large LCD display is one of its best features, making it very easy for users to identify targets quickly. Its sensitivity settings are quite intuitive, and the audio feedback is helpful for pinpointing objects. However, one downside of the F44 is the lack of included accessories. Users must purchase headphones or other accessories separately, which could be an added expense.

Garrett ACE 400
In contrast, the Garrett ACE 400 offers more comprehensive accessory support. It comes with ClearSound Easy Stow Headphones, an ACE Environmental Cover-Up to protect from weather elements, and a searchcoil cover, making it a more complete package right out of the box. Its user-friendly interface and additional features like the iron audio discrimination button ensure that even beginners can enjoy using it without feeling overwhelmed by complex settings.

Value for Money

Fisher F44
The Fisher F44, while slightly more expensive than the Garrett ACE 400, offers exceptional value for money if you prioritize weatherproofing and deep-target sensitivity. It is perfect for outdoor enthusiasts who are looking for a more rugged and durable detector. The lack of included accessories is a downside, but the overall performance and ease of use make it worth the investment for those who intend to use it in a variety of environments.

Garrett ACE 400
The Garrett ACE 400 offers great value for money as well, especially considering it includes several useful accessories right out of the box. Its performance is solid, and the inclusion of features like iron audio and electronic pinpointing make it a great option for those looking to fine-tune their treasure hunting experience. While it lacks weatherproofing, its versatility, ease of use, and included features make it a strong contender for beginners.

FAQ

Which metal detector is better for beginners, the Fisher F44 or Garrett ACE 400?

The Garrett ACE 400 is generally considered more beginner-friendly due to its user-friendly interface, clear audio feedback, and included accessories such as headphones and a searchcoil cover. The simplicity of the digital target ID and iron audio feature also makes it easier for new users to understand what they’re detecting. However, the Fisher F44 also has an easy-to-read LCD display and is fairly intuitive, but it lacks the included accessories that might be helpful for someone just starting out.

Is the Fisher F44 suitable for all-weather conditions?

Yes, the Fisher F44 has a weatherproof design, which makes it ideal for outdoor use in various weather conditions, including rain. Its durability ensures that it can handle the elements, making it a great choice for users who hunt in unpredictable weather or on wet terrains like beaches. In contrast, the Garrett ACE 400 does not have the same level of weather protection, so it may not be the best choice for use in wet conditions.

Does the Garrett ACE 400 have any features that help with unwanted metal detection?

Yes, the Garrett ACE 400 comes with an Iron Audio feature, which allows users to hear unwanted metals, such as bottle caps and nails, before they start digging. This helps to avoid wasting time on unworthy targets. The ability to hear the iron signals helps users focus on more valuable finds, making the ACE 400 a great option for areas with a lot of trash.

How does the pinpointing feature on both detectors compare?

Both the Fisher F44 and Garrett ACE 400 come with pinpointing features, but they function slightly differently. The Fisher F44 uses a standard pinpointing mode, which can be effective for general use. On the other hand, the Garrett ACE 400 has an electronic pinpointing system, which provides more accuracy and helps to locate targets more precisely. The electronic pinpointing feature on the ACE 400 makes it easier to recover items once detected, especially in areas with dense soil or debris.

Which metal detector offers better value for money?

Both detectors offer good value for money, but in different ways. The Fisher F44, although a bit more expensive, provides excellent performance with its weatherproof design, sensitivity, and depth range. It is ideal for users looking for a more durable, all-weather detector. On the other hand, the Garrett ACE 400 offers great value by including essential accessories like headphones and a searchcoil cover, making it a complete package for beginners. It is also slightly more affordable, making it a solid choice for those who are just starting in metal detecting.

Conclusion

Both the Fisher F44 and the Garrett ACE 400 are excellent choices for metal detecting enthusiasts, offering a range of features that suit both beginners and experienced hunters. The Fisher F44 is the better choice for those who need a weatherproof and durable detector that can handle a variety of conditions. Its sensitivity and depth range are excellent for those who want a more serious treasure hunting experience. On the other hand, the Garrett ACE 400 is a fantastic option for users who value ease of use, included accessories, and features like iron audio for trash discrimination. Ultimately, the decision depends on whether you prioritize durability and sensitivity (Fisher F44) or a more complete package with accessories (Garrett ACE 400).

Enjoyed this guide of Fisher F44 vs. Garrett ACE 400? Then be sure to check out our other metal detector guides.

• Best Metal Detectors for Beginners
• Best Metal Detectors for Beach
• Best Metal Detectors for Kids
• Best Metal Detectors for Depth
• Best Metal Detectors for Finding Gold